The Best and "Worst" Skid Steer Loader Models: An Honest Review Based on User and Expert Opinions
Choosing the right skid steer involves balancing power, reliability, operator comfort, and the crucial factor of local dealer support. Based on user feedback and expert opinions from 2024-2025, no single brand is universally "perfect" or "terrible"; performance often depends on the specific model, application, and maintenance routine. Here is a breakdown of top-rated brands and insights into where some models might fall short.
Popular Models: S650 and S750 (mid-to-large frame wheeled loaders).
Pros:
Versatility: Excellent compatibility with a vast range of attachments.
Resale Value: Command strong resale prices.
Durability: Proven reliability and robust build.
Cons:
Initial Cost: Generally have a higher upfront purchase price than some competitors.
Popular Models: 262D/246D series and the newer D3 series.
Pros:
Operator Comfort: Often cited as having the best cabs and advanced controls.
Performance: Powerful performance and smooth hydraulics, ideal for demanding commercial jobs.
Dealer Support: Strong nationwide dealer networks.
Cons:
Price Premium: Command a higher price point.
Maintenance Complexity: Newer models with advanced tech can be complex to service.
Popular Models: SSV65 and SSV75.
Pros:
Fuel Efficiency: Known for great fuel economy.
Value: A good balance of performance and price point.
Reliable Engines: Utilizes reliable Kubota diesel engines.
Cons:
Cab Noise/Comfort: Some users report cabs can be loud or slightly less refined than premium brands.
Popular Models: SR210 and SV280/SV340B.
Pros:
Performance: Known for strong lifting power and performance.
Serviceability: Designed with easy-to-access service points.
Operator Comfort: Feature comfortable cabs and intuitive controls.
Cons:
May not hold resale value quite as strongly as Bobcat or CAT.
Older John Deere Models: Some operators have reported chronic electrical issues with older G-Series models. However, the newer P-Tier models are designed with significant improvements.
JCB: While praised for innovation like the unique side-entry Powerboom™ (a major safety feature), some users describe older JCB models as "especially terrible machines" and difficult to work on.
Takeuchi (Parts Availability): Though noted as very strong machines, a common complaint is the difficulty and cost of finding parts and the compact design making service access difficult.
Ultimately, the ideal skid steer depends on individual needs, including workload, budget, local dealer support, and preferred controls. A machine suitable for one application may not be for another.
Brands like Rippa Machinery Group are highlighted as a budget-friendly option, particularly outside North America and Europe, focusing on cost-effective, functional, and reliable compact equipment for small businesses and owner-operators.
